Skip to main content

Table 6 Comparison of the QCard-NM and QPS packages in RV segmentation

From: QCard-NM: Developing a semiautomatic segmentation method for quantitative analysis of the right ventricle in non-gated myocardial perfusion SPECT imaging

QCard-NM

QPS v2015.1

Spherical model

Ellipsoidal model

The segmentation results are highly dependent on the RV model

The segmentation results are highly dependent on the RV count profiles

Users can modify the model to avoid segmentation failure in the presence of extracardiac activity

Users can not interfere with the segmentation process

Automatic segmentation may fail in case of RV dilation

Automatic segmentation may fail in case of intense extracardiac uptake near the RV

Highly agreeable with the manually drawn physician’s contour

No data availability

Statistically non-significant difference between repeated supine/prone scans in RV segmentation

Statistically significant difference between repeated supine/prone scans in RV segmentation

Calculated RV cavity volume is highly correlated with actual phantom RV size

Calculated RV cavity volume is poorly correlated with actual phantom RV size

Present the quantitative RV perfusion analysis

Present the gated RV functional parameters