Skip to main content

Table 1 Mean activity of 45 lesions in a clinical study across six reconstruction methods (Q.Clear with β values of 100, 200, 300, 400, 500, and OSEM), categorized by lesion size: 27 small lesions (diameter ⩽ 10 mm) and 18 large lesions (diameter > 10 mm), and individual tumor type identification (primary rectal tumor, lung metastasis, pelvic metastasis)

From: The effects of various penalty parameter values in Q.Clear algorithm for rectal cancer detection on 18F-FDG images using a BGO-based PET/CT scanner: a phantom and clinical study

Small lesions (diameter ⩽ 10 mm)

Lesion

β value = 100

β value = 200

β value = 300

β value = 400

β value = 500

OSEM

Tumor type

1

14.62

14.05

13.5

13.05

12.63

10.94

Primary rectal tumor

2

33.66

32.93

32.29

31.7

31.16

28.24

Primary rectal tumor

3

26.59

25.73

24.97

24.24

23.55

19.91

Primary rectal tumor

4

33.85

32.94

32.16

31.41

30.71

26.34

Primary rectal tumor

5

33.2

30.52

28.26

26.26

24.49

19.87

Primary rectal tumor

6

19.71

19.17

18.65

18.16

17.7

15.57

Primary rectal tumor

7

16.6

16

15.4

14.82

14.29

14.26

Primary rectal tumor

8

36.4

35.88

35.36

34.83

34.31

30.98

Lung metastasis

9

26.29

25.62

24.99

24.37

23.78

22.29

Lung metastasis

10

11.35

10.96

11.71

10.57

10.21

9.11

Lung metastasis

11

12.05

11.59

12.48

11.14

10.74

9.72

Lung metastasis

12

13.61

12.59

14.88

11.75

11.04

9.18

Lung metastasis

13

18.59

16.93

20.68

15.62

14.58

12.85

Lung metastasis

14

17.56

17.35

17.12

16.86

16.59

15.5

Lung metastasis

15

17.37

16.74

16.21

15.74

15.34

14.01

Lung metastasis

16

12.27

12.01

11.74

11.49

11.22

10.29

Pelvic metastasis

17

14.054

13.82

13.59

13.37

13.14

12.29

Pelvic metastasis

18

19.86

17.69

15.8

14.27

13.017

10.04

Pelvic metastasis

19

18.4

17.71

16.32

15.78

15.25

13.16

Pelvic metastasis

20

13.92

13.62

12.65

12.24

11.88

11.02

Pelvic metastasis

21

21.52

18.42

17.74

17.39

17.01

16.33

Pelvic metastasis

22

23.08

21.07

19.75

18.78

18.43

17.55

Pelvic metastasis

23

25.32

22.34

21.27

20.73

20.27

18.67

Pelvic metastasis

24

19.39

16.78

15.43

14.25

13.2

11.42

Pelvic metastasis

25

14.92

14.65

14.25

13.79

13.46

12.31

Pelvic metastasis

26

17.05

14.1

12.59

11.68

10.87

11.22

Pelvic metastasis

27

40.26

38.34

36.77

35.48

34.22

27.96

Pelvic metastasis

Large lesions (diameter > 10 mm)

Lesion

β value = 100

β value = 200

β value = 300

β value = 400

β value = 500

OSEM

Tumor type

1

30.71

30.27

29.84

29.45

29.07

29.59

Primary rectal tumor

2

21.92

21.4

21.02

20.72

20.46

20.78

Primary rectal tumor

3

34.89

34.08

33.35

32.67

32.04

31.56

Primary rectal tumor

4

30.22

29.79

29.42

29.1

28.81

27.5

Primary rectal tumor

5

27.51

27.29

27.06

26.86

26.66

25.77

Primary rectal tumor

6

8.99

8.87

8.78

8.67

8.51

7.34

Primary rectal tumor

7

9.06

8.94

8.84

8.74

8.62

8.28

Primary rectal tumor

8

8.22

7.91

7.28

6.98

6.88

6.23

Primary rectal tumor

9

17.36

17.83

17.3

17.27

17.24

16.62

Lung metastasis

10

18.05

18.27

17.8

17.55

17.31

16.51

Lung metastasis

11

43.14

42.06

41.41

40.99

40.7

38.29

Lung metastasis

12

22.7

20.23

19.35

18.65

18.06

19.85

Lung metastasis

13

15.79

14.29

13.35

12.65

12.12

14.16

Pelvic metastasis

14

32.43

28.86

26.9

26.17

25.44

26.89

Pelvic metastasis

15

26.21

23.14

21.69

20.67

19.87

19.5

Pelvic metastasis

16

36.17

35.03

34.08

33.26

32.44

30.64

Pelvic metastasis

17

10.06

8.7

8.042

7.6

7.26

6.31

Pelvic metastasis

18

16.39

12.39

10.53

9.58

8.92

8.55

Pelvic metastasis